The sentencing trial for Tanner Horner – who pleaded guilty to killing 7‑year‑old Athena Strand – is now expected to last longer than originally planned, as the judge continues reviewing expert testimony before allowing the jury to hear it.
For several days, the trial has proceeded without the jury present while the judge evaluates a long list of defense experts. The process, which is standard in a capital murder case, has added significant time to the proceedings.
A verdict may still be at least two weeks away, attorneys said in court Tuesday.
Defense outlines medical history
Four additional expert witnesses testified Tuesday as part of the defense’s effort to outline Horner’s medical and mental‑health history. The judge must determine whether each expert’s testimony is admissible before the jury can hear it.
The witnesses included a psychologist, a university professor, and specialists in neuroscience and prison behavior.
The most critical testimony came from the psychologist – the only expert who personally evaluated Horner. She told the court that Horner meets the criteria for several conditions, including PTSD, autism spectrum disorder, and major depressive disorder.
![]()
Jury set to return Wednesday
Not all of the experts reviewed by the judge will necessarily testify before the jury.
The jury is scheduled to return on Wednesday morning. The judge said he expects the defense to rest its case on May 4. If that timeline holds, closing arguments would take place on May 5, and a sentencing verdict could come that same day.
CBS News Texas will continue to follow developments in the case.
News
New Details: More texts between Mackenzie Shirilla and Dominic Russo have surfaced from before the d3adly crash she caused at 100 mph
Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Correction Disturbing text messages have been revealed between Mackenzie Shirilla and her boyfriend, Dominic Russo, before she ultimately took his life and the life of his friend, Davion Flanagan, in a horrific, fatal crash. The…
50 More Pages: The messages Mackenzie Shirilla exchanged with Dominic Russo before the fatal 100-mph cr@sh are now drawing fresh attention
Ohio Department of Rehabilitation and Correction Disturbing text messages have been revealed between Mackenzie Shirilla and her boyfriend, Dominic Russo, before she ultimately took his life and the life of his friend, Davion Flanagan, in a horrific, fatal crash. The…
Dad In Denial: Police bodycam footage has revealed a disturbing side of Mackenzie Shirilla’s father as he struggles to accept the truth about her
Strongsville Police Department After Mackenzie Shirilla was arrested in connection to the fatal car crash that killed her boyfriend, Dominic Russo, and friend Davion Flanagan, her dad went down to the police station to yell at the officers for arresting the “dumb 18-year-old.” The…
Breaking: Mackenzie Shirilla’s dad is fighting back with a 200-page appeal file and new evidence in support of his daughter
The shocking car crash that killed Shirilla’s boyfriend, Dominic Russo, and their friend, Davion Flanagan, is the subject of the new Netflix documentary, “The Crash.” Mackenzie Shirilla and Steve Shirilla in ‘The Crash’.Credit: Netflix (2) Mackenzie Shirilla’s father, Steve Shirilla, continues…
B@il Granted: Nick Pasqual’s release after the brutal st@bbing of his ex-girlfriend more than 20 t!mes is sparking major reaction
Nick Pasqual was convicted of the attempted murder of Allie Shehorn Nick Pasqual and Allie Shehorn.Credit : Maury Phillips/WireImage; GoFundMe An actor who once appeared on How I Met Your Mother was sentenced to 32 years to life for the attempted…
“I loved him so much”: Newly released five-hour recordings from Mackenzie Shirilla’s pr!son calls exposed her emotional confession about love behind b@rs
She’s apparently been getting loads of attention from boys Mackenzie Shirilla is apparently getting involved in a bit of a prison romance, and has been happy to gush about the new boy in her life during phone calls with her…
End of content
No more pages to load