CLEVELAND — “Hell on Wheels” killer Mackenzie Shirilla’s’s parents were always more concerned with winning their daughter’s approval than raising her right, a former friend told The Post.
“From what I see, they didn’t really care about her. They cared more to have her approval,” said Jaina Maynard, who met Mackenzie in middle school.
“Kenzie runs the show — she runs her parents,” the 21-year-old added. “They shouldn’t have been her friend. They should have been her parents.”
Maynard said Steve and Natalie Shirilla enabled their daughter’s “beyond spoiled brat” behavior for years before she intentionally plowed her car into a brick wall in July 2022, killing her ex-boyfriend Dominic Russo and friend Davion Flanagan.
Mom Natalie “kind of seemed like one of the girls,” the old pal recalled.
“She didn’t seem like a full-on mom. She felt like one of our friends.”
But Mackenzie routinely took advantage of that dynamic — and “was really emotionally and verbally abusive to her mother,” Maynard claimed.
She recalled one incident during eighth grade when Natalie was driving a group of Mackenzie’s friends to a haunted house.
“Kenzie said word for word: ‘Mom, shut the f–k up.’ And guess what? Her mom shut the f–k up,” Maynard said.
Moments later, a seemingly unfazed Natalie was back to offering the girls snacks.
“She was so, so nice after Kenzie just treated her like utter s–t,” Maynard said. “Whatever Kenzie says, her mom just does.”
Mackenzie also slammed Natalie as “so effing annoying” and “a bitch” in conversations with her baby-faced pals at the time, according to Maynard.
“Her parents have done everything for her since she was a little kid, and she’s just badmouthing her parents every chance she can get because they won’t buy her the next collection of Bape hoodies,” she explained, referring to streetwear sweatshirts that run between $300 and $600.
“That’s the reason her mom was a bitch.”
Still, Mackenzie was always decked out in “nice clothes, all the new shoes, the nice bags” courtesy of Steve and Natalie, Maynard said.
“Obviously her parents gave her everything … ’til she started dating Dom, and Dom ended up providing for her,” the former friend continued — and called Mackenzie “the definition of a spoiled brat.”
Mackenzie, now 21, is serving two concurrent 15-years-to-life sentences in an Ohio women’s prison after being convicted in 2023 of murdering Russo and Flanagan. She is appealing her conviction for a second time.
Her parents have faced renewed scrutiny for their seemingly permissive approach to their daughter’s behavior and hardline defense of her horrific crimes, as captured in a new popular Netflix documentary, “The Crash.”
“I knew she was smoking dope — I don’t have a problem with her smoking dope,” Steve said in the film, while addressing Mackenzie’s frequent marijuana consumption throughout her teens.
“If you’re going to smoke a drug, that’s the one I believe you should take … you know, she’s not shooting up,” he continued.
The questionable comment got Steve suspended from his teaching job at a pre-K-to-8 school outside Cleveland, where administrators said they were investigating allegations of his “poor judgment” last month.
Maynard praised the school’s decision and claimed the Shirillas weren’t honest about the full extent of their daughter’s drug usage.
“They knew that their daughter was driving and smoking weed and speeding,” she said. “Her mom literally follows her on social media and Kenzie would post this freely.”
The ex-pal claimed Mackenzie regularly posted videos of herself smoking from a bong on Snapchat as early as middle school.
“She would go home and immediately sit in front of the camera, light her bong up and dance in front of the camera and post the videos,” she said.
“I was smoking in middle school, so I would actually get weed from her,” Maynard alleged, while dismissing online rumors that Russo was a drug dealer as “completely false.”
Maynard also accused Mackezie of “severely tormenting” classmates — including one girl who allegedly left the school district after the killer encouraged her to harm herself in middle school.
“It got to the point where this girl ended up checking herself into a mental facility and then left the district of Strongsville altogether … it was horrible,” she claimed.
Steve and Natalie have continued to maintain their daughter’s innocence and recently expressed dissatisfaction about how the Netflix documentary was edited.
The couple also drew backlash during Mackenzie’s sentencing hearing, when Natalie referred to Flanagan as “a new friend” while pleading with the judge for leniency.
“What does that mean? His life was worthless?” the judge demanded, prompting Natalie to apologize to the mourning families.
Steve and Natalie could not be reached for comment.
News
Court Update: A judge has addressed Karmelo Anthony’s chances of appealing, pointing to one issue that could stop the process
Collin County jury sentenced Anthony to 35 years in prison for the fatal stabbing of 17-year-old Austin Metcalf at a Texas track meet last year The judge who presided over the high-profile murder trial of Karmelo Anthony is standing by…
Found At Sea: Amada Mia Brown was recovered off Laguna Beach, and the object she was still holding has left many people stunned
LAGUNA BEACH, Calif. (KABC) — The body of the 5-year-old girl who was swept away into the ocean in Laguna Beach has been recovered, authorities said Thursday afternoon. The girl’s father identified her as Amada Mia Brown. Aaron Brown described his…
Latest Update: Search crews found Amada Mia Brown at sea near Laguna Beach, but what she was still holding has become the most d!sturbing detail
LAGUNA BEACH, Calif. (KABC) — The body of the 5-year-old girl who was swept away into the ocean in Laguna Beach has been recovered, authorities said Thursday afternoon. The girl’s father identified her as Amada Mia Brown. Aaron Brown described his…
Where Did The Money Go?: Claims that Karmelo Anthony’s family used donation money to improve their lifestyle are drawing intense attention
Did Karmelo Anthony’s family buy a house with GiveSendGo money? A fact-check found no proof. Karmelo Anthony was charged in the fatal stabbing of 17-year-old Austin Metcalf during a track meet in Frisco, Texas. On Tuesday, a jury found him guilty of murder in…
After Sentencing: While Karmelo Anthony’s family mourned and said everyone lost, Austin Metcalf’s family said they finally got the outcome they were hoping for
The father of Texas teenager Karmelo Anthony said “nobody wins” after a jury rejected his son’s claims of self-defense and convicted him of murder in the stabbing death of fellow student-athlete Austin Metcalf. Anthony was accused of fatally stabbing Metcalf at a…
“People want us d3ad”: Heartbreaking recordings reveal more than two hours of raw emotion from the families at the center of the Karmelo Anthony and Austin Metcalf case
The murder trial of Karmelo Anthony may be over, but the pain and grief for both his family and the family of the victim, Austin Metcalf, endures. Both families opened up to CBS News Texas on Wednesday, not only about the verdict…
End of content
No more pages to load



